Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 17 Summary of assigned priorities (Israeli perspective) for Principle 3

From: A structured scientific solution to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict: the analytic hierarchy process approach

Israeli benefits from Palestinian concessions Priorities P1 P2  
Accepting the global recognition of Jerusalem (in its new borders) as the capital of Israel 0.2812 0.6 0.688  
Increasing international and regional support for Israel 0.1508 0.75 0.663  
Transfer of full governmental and municipal responsibility for the Palestinian residents of Eastern Jerusalem, while sharing social costs 0.0587 0 0  
Security 0.0481 0 0  
Receiving international legitimization to the Jewish neighborhood in East Jerusalem 0.2189 0.625 0.575  
Strengthen Israeli democracy 0.2423 0.438 0.055  
   0.5246 0.4324  
Israeli costs from Israeli concessions Priorities I1 I2 I3
Hurting the feelings of the global Jewish people by conceding on the right of Jews to live everywhere in Jerusalem 0.2255 0.402 0.875 0.12
Increasing potential friction due to the dual management of the city, increasing inefficiencies 0.1582 0.173 0.967 0.12
Hindering the ability to effectively zone and plan super-infrastructure inside and around Jerusalem 0.0954 0.283 0.533 0.287
Loss of security control 0.4271 0.317 0.587 0.67
Loss of demographic control 0.0938 0.37 0.503 0.553
   0.3152 0.6989 0.4115
Israeli perception of Palestinian benefits from Israeli concessions Priorities I1 I2 I3
Fulfill our national aspiration and dignity 0.3699 0.503 0.667 0.637
Enforcing the Palestinian national identity 0.2964 0.587 0.367 0.587
Free worship of the three monotheistic religions 0.0562 0 0 0
Social benefit by preserving the social fabric 0.1266 0.387 0.07 0.203
Economic benefit by developing the tourism industry and other aspects of life in the city 0.1509 0.1 0.07 0.583
   0.4241 0.3747 0.5232
Israeli perception of Palestinian costs from Palestinian concessions Priorities P1 P2  
Political costs by accepting compromise within the land swap approach on parts of the city where Israeli settlements exist 0.5905 0.883 0.367  
Limiting the potential urban, economic and social development of the city arising from the existence of Israeli settlements interlocked within the Palestinian capital 0.4095 0.317 0.337  
   0.6513 0.3544  
Palestinian actions     
P1. Full Palestinian cooperation during transfer of power and beyond it     
P2. Accepting international monitoring on the compliance of the transfer of power process